There’s a bunch of services on the web nowadays that are targeted at introducing people to new music. What with the advent of my own musical saturation (some 60Gb in my pocket right now) and juggling listening to music and Podcasts of varying nature, finding new tracks has become quite a task, particularly as I’m one of the most time-poor of the time-poor. Kids. Pah!There simply isn’t time anymore to go to gigs, clubs, listen to various radio stations.
That is until you actually start investing some time in some of the great services that are available. That said, there are still some fundamentals missing from the overall ‘Service Design’ of these services but we’re on our way.
I’ve been investing my time in using Last.FM as I know that it’s one of those services that only has value once you’ve used it for a period of time. There are a number of these things out there, Last.FM, Pandora, MOG etc..
For those of you who don’t know what Last.FM is you can view my Last.FM profile. The aim of the service is to help you discover new music via your current listening patterns.
The service utilises the ‘Recently Played’ playlist from your iPod and/or iTunes player (of course it works for those Windowy type things too on Windows Media Player). It creates a number of different charts based on your behaviour, most listened this week, ever etc…
Then it does 3 things to try and recommend you new music. Firstly it gives you ‘Neighbours’ or people with similar listening habits, I’ve been a Neighbour with a guy from Scandinavia called TipOne for ages now as we have quite similar tastes in music. I can look into my neighbour profiles and manually look fro artists that I haven’t heard of in their charts. Chances are, I might like something if I can be bothered to sit there listening to it.
Then there is the ‘Recommended’ section of your homepage where Last.FM places things you might like, which personally I always ignore, forget to look at and when I have it’s been a rubbish suggestion.
I mean Kasabian - me…? Have a word with yourself.
Then there is the Last.FM Player which I think is AWESOME and may end up costing me lots of money. I can listen to a variety of radio stations based on my habits. ‘Recommendation Radio’ does just exactly that, it plays a constant stream of things I might like. I can tell it ‘No, skip this’ or ‘Yay, love it’ and it will continue to filter accordingly.
It has all the usual stuff you’d expect, tagging etc (though this has only become easy for mac users in the last player update - well done Last.FM).
I’m finding new stuff all the time using this player which is cool - theor problem is, I go elsewhere to buy it as the buying experience is more integrated, sorry chaps.
Another slight issue with these services is that you have to use them for a while before they start showing you any benefit because you have to build up your habits. I think they should try and make use of your historical data because it only starts building your profile from the day you subscribe, yet there is 5 years worth of usage on my iPod and in my iTunes.
They could seek to introduce
Come on Last.FM this is obvious isn’t it?
Then there is Pandora, the front end of the Music Genome Project. They claim to have spent on average 30 minutes deconstructing over 10,000 tracks into over 400 attributes. They mark up the musical DNA track-by-track against facets such as tempo, vocal tone, arrangement, composition, instruments used, genre, etc.
In-fact, I can’t do their attributes any real justice sat here on the train on the way into work - they really are complex and detailed and herein lies the power of the service. Each track is analysed in the truest sense of the term, unlike comparable services who may use broad relationships between artists, record labels, genres, albums and tracks - George Clinton is Similar to James Brown. Pandora compares the DNA of each track.
I’ve always found this a limitation of the Gracenote CD DB ( a central repository that defines what classification/genre music belongs too), it’s generally always at an album level, yet many albums I have are mutliple genre and not everything outside ‘Western Culture’ is called ‘World Music’.
With Pandora, you sit there and listen to the player and filter tracks out as you feel it. The profile you develop is based on what you like and what you don’t like. I wonder how much serendipity they throw in?
I mean, just because I always listen to hiphop, it doesn’t mean that I wouldn’t like some Indie?
Lastly, there is Mog. From what I gather so far, Mog is just like Last.FM and as I haven’t used it yet, I can’t really qualify it. Other than to say, what I find interesting about these type of services, Flickr, Last.FM, iTunes, iPhoto even, is that the more time I invest in using them, the more tied to the service I have to become.
My inclination to trial Mog is inhibited by the fact that I’ve already started dealing with Last.FM and I can see no easy way to transfer or make use of this data.
They own my metadata.
I’m locked in, unless I can easily get out.
Which I can’t.
There’s a tip for service designers, make sure migration from existing services is possible because though your shiny new photoblogging tool might kick Flickr into touch, I’ve spent so much time building my profile, moving is not desirable. Even if it’s better.